Late Night Mexican Food in NYC: A Flavorful Detour to Cítrico Café in Astoria

Good vibes, great food, even better company.

It’s getting later into the night, but the energy of New York City is still buzzing. You’ve been out with friends, laughing, sharing stories, and exploring neighborhoods you hadn’t walked through in a while. Somehow, the night led you to Astoria, Queens—an area known for its cultural richness and diversity. And now, the craving hits. Not just any craving, but something bold, savory, and deeply satisfying. You pull out your phone and search: late night Mexican food in NYC.

One name keeps popping up: Cítrico Café.

A Late-Night Mexican Food in NYC: A Hidden Gem That Feels Like a Discovery.

Tucked away on Steinway Street, Cítrico Café glows from within—dim lighting spilling out through tall windows, the faint sound of Latin rhythms drifting into the sidewalk. If you're searching for late night Mexican food in NYC, this is where ambiance and flavor come together. It feels inviting without trying too hard. The rustic-modern interior blends warm wood textures with sleek accents, giving it a style that’s both upscale and easygoing.

You walk in and are greeted by the comforting smell of slow-cooked meats and fresh spices. The space is humming. There’s a DJ warming up in the corner, or maybe it's a group of musicians unpacking their instruments—it’s one of those nights. You didn’t expect live music, but that’s what makes the city magical.

Grilled to perfection, served with corazón.

Flavors That Keep You Up Past Midnight

While the vibe sets the tone, it’s the food that locks you in. Cítrico Café doesn’t do shortcuts. Their dishes are layered, colorful, and built with care.

Here’s what stands out on the late-night menu:

• Birria Tacos with Consommé: Slow-braised beef tucked into crispy tortillas, served with a rich, spiced consommé for dipping. Messy, flavorful, and absolutely satisfying.

• Chilaquiles (Rojo or Verde): Fried tortillas simmered in bold salsas, topped with crema, queso fresco, and your choice of protein. It’s the perfect mix of crunch, heat, and comfort.

• Tuna Tiradito: Thin slices of sushi-grade tuna dressed in lime and chile oil. Light, elegant, and sharp—ideal for when you want something fresh.

• Guacamole with Charred Pineapple: Creamy, smoky, and sweet. A signature twist that adds depth to every chip.

Even the simple things—like house-made salsas or warm tortillas—are dialed up to eleven. It’s late, sure, but your taste buds are wide awake.

Quench your thirst with a refreshing and flavorful cocktail.

Cocktails That Speak for Themselves

One thing that keeps locals coming back is the bar. Cítrico Café takes agave spirits seriously. Tequilas and mezcals are infused in-house with ingredients like tamarind, hibiscus, jalapeño, and pineapple.

The result? Cocktails that feel like crafted experiences.

• Hibiscus Mezcal Margarita – floral and smoky with just the right amount of tang

• Spicy Jalapeño Tequila Mule – a bold kick followed by a cool ginger finish

• Tamarind Paloma – tart, citrusy, and refreshingly complex

You can also order a mezcal flight if you're feeling adventurous. The bartenders know their stuff and are always up for a quick rundown if you’re curious.

An Atmosphere That Matches the Mood

What makes this spot stand out isn’t just the menu—it’s how the place feels. Cítrico Café captures that rare balance between lively and relaxed. On any given night, you might find couples sipping cocktails in a booth, a group of friends sharing tacos, or solo diners reading the room with a mezcal in hand.

Then there’s the music. Some nights it’s background ambiance. Other nights, the band sets up and suddenly your casual meal turns into something more—a moment. There’s no cover, no fanfare, just a flow of good energy and community.

It’s the kind of place where you come for dinner and end up staying for another drink. Or maybe two.

Enjoy an evening of live music with a touch of latin fusion.

Queens Does It Better

There’s no shortage of late-night bites in New York, but Queens—and especially Astoria—has a unique rhythm. It’s multicultural, welcoming, and filled with independent gems like Cítrico Café. This isn’t just about feeding hunger; it’s about feeding experience.

When you’re wandering NYC past 9 p.m. and looking for something different—something with flavor, culture, and warmth—this is your spot. Whether you’re ending a night out or just starting one, Cítrico Café delivers.